Kansas City W vs NJ/NY Gotham FC W Match Recap - Nov 9, 2025

Kansas City W Stunned by NJ/NY Gotham FC W in Extra Time Upset

NJ/NY Gotham FC W pulled off a stunning upset against Kansas City W, winning 2-1 after extra time in the NWSL quarter-finals at CPKC Stadium. This match marked a dramatic shift in momentum for a Gotham side that had struggled in recent weeks, while Kansas City faced a harsh reality check after dominating the regular season.

Gotham's victory came as a surprise, especially considering their recent form. They entered the match with just one win in their last five games, including a disappointing 3-2 loss to North Carolina Courage just days prior. Yet, they found a way to rise to the occasion when it mattered most. The turning point came in the 112th minute when Gotham scored the decisive goal, sending shockwaves through the stadium and leaving Kansas City reeling.

Lavelle, who had been a bright spot for Gotham throughout the season, played a crucial role in this match. After scoring late in their previous game against North Carolina, she continued her form by contributing significantly to Gotham's attacking play. Her ability to create space and find teammates was instrumental in breaking down Kansas City's defense, which had been formidable throughout the regular season.

Kansas City, on the other hand, entered this match with high expectations after finishing first in the league. They had won four of their last five matches, including a solid 2-0 victory over Gotham just weeks earlier. However, they struggled to find their rhythm against a determined Gotham side. Despite controlling possession for much of the match, Kansas City could not convert their chances into goals. Their only score came from Debinha, who netted in the 54th minute, giving them a brief lead before Gotham equalized.

The first half saw Kansas City dominate possession but fail to capitalize on their opportunities. They managed only two shots on target compared to Gotham's three, highlighting their inability to convert control into meaningful chances. The second half began with renewed energy from Kansas City, and Debinha's goal seemed to set them on course for victory. Yet, Gotham responded quickly, leveling the score just minutes later through a well-placed shot that caught Kansas City's defense off guard.

As the match progressed into extra time, both teams appeared fatigued but determined. Kansas City pushed forward, hoping to regain the lead, but Gotham's defense held firm. The tension mounted as each team sought that elusive breakthrough. Ultimately, it was Gotham who found it, capitalizing on a defensive lapse from Kansas City to score the winner.

This result not only shifts the narrative for both teams but also raises questions about Kansas City's ability to perform under pressure. Their recent form suggested they were primed for a deep playoff run, but this defeat exposes vulnerabilities that could haunt them moving forward. Meanwhile, Gotham's victory serves as a reminder of their potential and resilience, proving they can compete with the best when it counts.

Reflecting on my pre-match predictions, I certainly underestimated Gotham's capacity for an upset. I anticipated Kansas City's dominance would carry them through comfortably, but this match showcased the unpredictable nature of knockout football. As we look ahead, this result could redefine both teams' trajectories in the playoffs. For Kansas City, it's back to the drawing board; for Gotham, it's a moment of triumph that could spark a remarkable run in the tournament.